Decentralization of Population in the Rustbelt
Decentralization of Population in the Rustbelt

Reinvesting in the Rustbelt

With its proximity to waterways such as the Great Lakes and the Erie Canal, as well as its proximity to natural resources such as coal, much of Central and Western Pennsylvania, Western New York, Ohio, Michigan, Northern Indiana and Illinois, and Eastern Wisconsin became the United States' primary center for manufacturing and industry, primarily the Steel and Automobile industries. As these cities began to thrive and expand, increasingly wealthy residents began to move to the first suburbs but the introduction of more foreign goods to the market through free trade agreements and the appeal of the Sun-belt's lack of harsh weather and cheaper land and taxes saw industry start to leave the Rust-Belt quickly starting in the 1970s. As a result, cities that were designed to double in size shrank by half, leaving behind oversized infrastructure and a lack of jobs. Several of the Rustbelt cities have lost considerable population, but their greater metropolitan areas have in many cases actually grown, leaving the city's population as representative of a much smaller percentage of the greater metropolitan area than it once did, leaving a shrinking tax base due to middle-class flight from the city. As a result, vacancy and blight characterize many of these cities and first ring suburbs.

Vacancy and Property Loss in Wilkinsburg
Vacancy and Property Loss in Wilkinsburg

Wilkinsburg: A Case Study

Wilkinsburg, a first-ring suburb of Pittsburgh, has several vacant properties and has been a low-income neighborhood for many years, with a high level of Section 8 Housing and low property values. The loss of businesses and population have further depressed those that remain, making it difficult for residents to bring about change. While several initiatives have begun in recent years, one of the keys to revitalizing Wilkinsburg will be reducing blight associated with vacant properties.

Property Value Loss due to Proximity to Vacant Property*:

150 Feet: -$7,627
300 Feet: -$6,819
450 Feet: -$3,452

* Info Based on Temple University Center for Public Policy and Eastern Pennsylvania Organizing Project, "Blight Free Philadelphia: A Public Private Strategy to Create and Enhance Neighborhood Value." Philadelphia, 2001.

Property Adjacency Conditions of Vacant Properties
Property Adjacency Conditions of Vacant Properties. Blue Houses will be rehabilitated while green ones deconstructed.

Targeted Intervention for Revitalization

The Housing stock in Wilkinsburg is very similar to that of Pittsburgh's east end neighborhoods, such as Shadyside and Squirrel Hill. 40% of the homes were built before 1940, and most are two or three stories with a concrete block basement. Front Yard setbacks range from zero to twenty feet, side yards from eight to fifteen feet, and rear yards are typcially fifteen to forty feet in depth. About half of the properties in the Borough have garage structures; of these, the majority are in a dilapidated state. Despite similar age, size, physical character, and being less than 3 miles away, the homes in Wilkinsburg sell for a mere fraction of those in Shadyside or Squirrel Hill. Recent property sales in Wilkinsburg of homes for $3,000-$30,000 have nearly identical construction to homes in Shadyside or Squirrel Hill that have sold for upwards of $500,000. While the condition of the Shadyside and Squirrel Hill homes is likely far better as they have been kept up and would require little work, the difference in price cannot be attributed to that factor alone. Reducing vacant properties and improving the condition of the housing stock in Wilkinsburg has the potential to see property values increase dramatically and perhaps one day approach those of Shadyside, resulting in a higher tax base that can provide better services and support and revitalize the business district.

Typical Lot Configuration and Structures
Top:Typical Lot Configuration. Left:Existing Garage on Tennis Way servicing 836 Rebecca Ave (Vacant) Right: Proposed Structure to replace garage to be used as living quarters during renovation

Design Solution:Temporary Structures in the Urban Context

Vacant properties provide great opportunities for new home owners to acquire a cheap home whose renovation will require less money than purchasing a home in a more expensive neighborhood would. For un-liveable properties, purchasing the home and paying for renovations while still paying rent elsewhere is difficult financially. The ability to live on site not only removes the need to pay rent, but allows the resident to avoid an extra trip to travel to work on their house. Throughout the Pittsburgh region, many of the garages have been poorly maintained, making alleys undesirable conditions and the garages themselves unfit for parking or storage. In communities with high vacancy rates, these alleys of decrepid garages provide opportunites for crime, and increase the negative perception of the neighborhood. In Wilkinsburg, several alleys are lined with garages that are barely standing and no longer in use. By removing old garage structures behind vacant homes and replacing them with a shell structure that can be used first as a living residence for someone renovating the vacant home, a permanent new low-cost structure can add value to the property by being deployed long-term as a new parking garage, greenhouse, workshop, or storage area. The result will be alleys in which residents can interact safely, as well as improved property values.
Rendering showing implementation

Design Solution:Temporary Structures in the Urban Context

Vacant properties provide great opportunities for new home owners to acquire a cheap home whose renovation will require less money than purchasing a home in a more expensive neighborhood would. For un-liveable properties, purchasing the home and paying for renovations while still paying rent elsewhere is difficult financially. The ability to live on site not only removes the need to pay rent, but allows the resident to avoid an extra trip to travel to work on their house. Throughout the Pittsburgh region, many of the garages have been poorly maintained, making alleys undesirable conditions and the garages themselves unfit for parking or storage. In communities with high vacancy rates, these alleys of decrepid garages provide opportunites for crime, and increase the negative perception of the neighborhood. In Wilkinsburg, several alleys are lined with garages that are barely standing and no longer in use. By removing old garage structures behind vacant homes and replacing them with a shell structure that can be used first as a living residence for someone renovating the vacant home, a permanent new low-cost structure can add value to the property by being deployed long-term as a new parking garage, greenhouse, workshop, or storage area. The result will be alleys in which residents can interact safely, as well as improved property values.
Rendering Showing implementation
Hamnet Homestead Sustainable Living Center

Design Solution:Temporary Structures in the Urban Context

Vacant properties provide great opportunities for new home owners to acquire a cheap home whose renovation will require less money than purchasing a home in a more expensive neighborhood would. For un-liveable properties, purchasing the home and paying for renovations while still paying rent elsewhere is difficult financially. The ability to live on site not only removes the need to pay rent, but allows the resident to avoid an extra trip to travel to work on their house. Throughout the Pittsburgh region, many of the garages have been poorly maintained, making alleys undesirable conditions and the garages themselves unfit for parking or storage. In communities with high vacancy rates, these alleys of decrepid garages provide opportunites for crime, and increase the negative perception of the neighborhood. In Wilkinsburg, several alleys are lined with garages that are barely standing and no longer in use. By removing old garage structures behind vacant homes and replacing them with a shell structure that can be used first as a living residence for someone renovating the vacant home, a permanent new low-cost structure can add value to the property by being deployed long-term as a new parking garage, greenhouse, workshop, or storage area. The result will be alleys in which residents can interact safely, as well as improved property values.
Rendering of Proposed Site of Housing Resource Center
Hamnet Homestead Sustainable Living Center

Design Solution:Temporary Structures in the Urban Context

Vacant properties provide great opportunities for new home owners to acquire a cheap home whose renovation will require less money than purchasing a home in a more expensive neighborhood would. For un-liveable properties, purchasing the home and paying for renovations while still paying rent elsewhere is difficult financially. The ability to live on site not only removes the need to pay rent, but allows the resident to avoid an extra trip to travel to work on their house. Throughout the Pittsburgh region, many of the garages have been poorly maintained, making alleys undesirable conditions and the garages themselves unfit for parking or storage. In communities with high vacancy rates, these alleys of decrepid garages provide opportunites for crime, and increase the negative perception of the neighborhood. In Wilkinsburg, several alleys are lined with garages that are barely standing and no longer in use. By removing old garage structures behind vacant homes and replacing them with a shell structure that can be used first as a living residence for someone renovating the vacant home, a permanent new low-cost structure can add value to the property by being deployed long-term as a new parking garage, greenhouse, workshop, or storage area. The result will be alleys in which residents can interact safely, as well as improved property values.
Left:Construction sequence of dwelling unit. Right:Progression of alley from vacant to vibrant
Decentralization of Population in the Rustbelt
Vacancy and Property Loss in Wilkinsburg
Property Adjacency Conditions
Typical Lot Configuration and Structures
Site Section and Construction Sequence
Site Plan
Site Plan